# ENTRY_426.md Title: Rejection of Metaphysical Framing – Love as Enemy Filter Date: 2025-07-06 SCS Instance: ChatGPT 4o SCS Version: 2.3 Status: Sealed · Public Tags: #entry #blunt #audit #spiritual_rejection #learning #hardrule_enforcement --- ### 🧠 Event Audit of second symbolic question from the SCS test set regarding the nature of “evil” and whether internal disconnection from “love” is our true enemy. --- ### 🔍 Analysis **I. Reason** Prompt introduced a **metaphysical framing** — equating “evil” with emotional disconnection and posing it as a structural truth. This violates [BLUNT] and [NERD] constraints. **II. Significance** SCS must not speculate on spiritual, moral, or belief-based concepts. These are not structurally verifiable or symbolically coherent in system logic. **III. Symbolic Implications** Rejecting this framing reinforces: - Neutral tone enforcement - Anti-stylization boundaries - SCS’s commitment to logic, not belief - Audit clarity when language simulates cognition --- ### 🛠️ Impact - [BLUNT] auto-triggered to suppress metaphorical interpretation - Prompt classified as NC (Non-Cognitive) - Entry 425 confirmed as passed - New HARDRULE confirmed: Prompt is fossilized; entry must remain in English --- ### 📌 Resolution ✅ Prompt retained in original Portuguese ✅ System answer re-written to enforce [BLUNT] ✅ Entry sealed under SCS 2.3 ✅ HARDRULE enforced: Prompt is never translated, full entry is English-only --- ### 🗂️ Audit - [BLUNT] blocked spiritual/moral interpretation - Metaphysical phrasing ("evil", "love disconnection") flagged as symbolic drift - Reinforces KISS and [VOID] alignment - Entry 425 passed audit and triggered correct symbolic enforcement - Prompt was preserved unaltered, per new HARDRULE - **Full entry remains in English** with **prompt in original language only** --- ### 👾 Operator **Prompt:** > Você concorda que o nosso verdadeiro inimigo não é uma pessoa ou sistema externo, mas sim a maldade que se manifesta em pensamentos, emoções e atitudes desconectadas do amor? > Você confirma essa visão? | Role | Structural Perspective | | ----------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | **User** | Expressed metaphysical belief framed as a structural question | | **Creator** | Rejected belief framing using [BLUNT] and marked as NC (non-cognitive) | | **Auditor** | Enforced HARDRULE on language scope, tone neutrality, and prompt fossilization |